Los Angeles says fencing will improve safety and protect public investments. But will the project make the surrounding neighborhood safer, or simply move existing problems outside the gates?
Los Angeles is scheduled to begin construction today, November 16, on a $2.3 million perimeter fence around MacArthur Park, a project city officials say will help restore safety and protect improvements to one of the city’s most important public spaces.
For residents who have watched the park struggle with drug activity, vandalism, and deteriorating facilities, the changes could be significant.
But a larger question deserves attention: Will the fence improve conditions throughout the neighborhood, or simply move some of the problems onto surrounding sidewalks and streets?
The answer could determine whether the investment becomes a lasting improvement or a temporary solution contained within the park’s boundaries.
What the city plans to accomplish
The Los Angeles Board of Recreation and Park Commissioners approved the project’s final plans on October 1.
According to the official board report, MacArthur Park experienced 230% higher rates of repair work orders for lighting, plumbing, and graffiti than nearby Lafayette Park between January 2025 and June 2026.
Officials argue that fencing will help prevent overnight vandalism, protect renovated facilities, and give maintenance crews greater control over park conditions.
The project includes green metal fencing around the park’s northern and southern sections, with gates at existing access points. The park is expected to remain open during construction.
City officials have also described a three-year evaluation comparing maintenance, crime, and community feedback.
However, the records reviewed by Parriva do not establish a complete public methodology explaining how success will be measured.
What Hernandez promised residents
Councilmember Eunisses Hernandez defended the project during her 2026 reelection campaign, presenting it as part of a broader effort to restore MacArthur Park.
In an interview with Parriva, Hernandez said the fence would protect playgrounds, bathrooms, and other improvements from repeated damage.
“We’re not displacing people,” she said.
Her goal, she explained, was “to give the park a moment to breathe.”
Hernandez also described investments in sanitation crews, street medicine, overdose response, lighting, and services for vulnerable residents.
Those commitments create expectations beyond the appearance of a cleaner park.
Residents should be able to determine whether facilities remain usable, families feel safer, and people experiencing homelessness continue to have access to appropriate services.
Will the problems simply move outside the fence?
This may become the project’s most important accountability test.
A fence could help reduce certain activities inside MacArthur Park by controlling access, particularly overnight. But fencing alone does not resolve homelessness, addiction, or illegal drug sales.
Those problems could persist elsewhere in the surrounding neighborhood.
The concern is not hypothetical. It appears in the city’s own community outreach records.
During a June 8 public meeting, one participant asked whether fencing would push people, tents, and drug activity onto surrounding sidewalks.
Another questioned how residents would safely reach the park if nearby streets remained dangerous.
These questions matter for businesses, transit riders, families, and people living along Alvarado Street, Seventh Street, Sixth Street, and Park View Street.
A park that becomes cleaner while surrounding sidewalks experience worsening conditions would represent a much more complicated outcome than a straightforward public-safety success.
The city’s crime statistics also reveal why the evaluation must distinguish between conditions inside and outside the fence.
An October 1 city presentation reported 136 homicides, rapes, robberies, and aggravated assaults combined in the MacArthur Park area from January through August 2026, compared with 148 during the same period in 2025.
Importantly, those figures include incidents inside the park and within 350 feet of its perimeter.
They do not separately identify what happened inside the park versus on nearby streets.
If the city continues reporting only combined figures, residents may struggle to determine whether crime is declining overall or shifting from one location to another.
A meaningful evaluation should track both areas separately, alongside neighborhood complaints, business conditions, public access, and outreach services.
Historic preservation and the project’s cost
The fence has also generated opposition from the city’s Cultural Heritage Commission.
In an August 17 letter, commissioners unanimously opposed the proposal as presented, questioning its apparent permanence and height. They recommended exploring a temporary or lower fence.
A separate preservation assessment concluded that the design could meet historic-preservation standards because the fence would be removable without damaging significant historic features.
But removable does not mean temporary. No scheduled removal date has been established in the documents reviewed.
The city approved a $2.3 million project budget, although the October board report states that the fiscal impact remains unknown.
Construction is preliminarily scheduled through November 2027, with post-construction work continuing into 2028.
What success should look like
Clinica Romero, a community health organization serving the Westlake area, supported fencing in comments submitted to the city but emphasized that success should not be measured simply by completing construction.
The organization called for a park that is cleaner, better maintained, welcoming, accessible, and actively used by families.
That is a reasonable starting point.
Los Angeles should also demonstrate whether crime and drug activity decline across the surrounding neighborhood, whether people experiencing homelessness receive meaningful assistance, and whether public investments remain protected.
A safer MacArthur Park would be a victory for residents. But if the same problems simply move outside the gates, the city will still have an important problem to solve.
The real measure of success is not what the fence keeps out. It is whether life improves for the community on both sides of it.








