California’s incoming governor and Los Angeles’ incoming mayor have made different kinds of promises. Here’s how voters can measure what each delivers.
California’s next governor and Los Angeles’ next mayor are preparing to take office with different approaches to a familiar political challenge: What should elected leaders promise, and how should voters judge whether they deliver?
Governor-elect Xavier Becerra has emphasized commitments to government action while expressing caution about guaranteeing broad outcomes. Mayor-elect Nithya Raman has set ambitious numerical targets, including tripling annual housing construction in Los Angeles and reducing street homelessness by 50% before the 2028 Olympics.
Both approaches create accountability, but they give voters different ways to measure success.
The important distinction is between promising to act, promising a result, and demonstrating that people’s lives have improved.
Becerra’s Promises: Actions Voters Can Verify
Becerra’s caution about guaranteeing outcomes has a history.
In an August interview with CalMatters, he described a lesson from his early congressional career. After initially opposing the North American Free Trade Agreement, he supported it following negotiations over labor protections. He later concluded that the agreement had failed to protect American workers as he had hoped.
That experience influenced his reluctance to make commitments without understanding their consequences.
On housing, Becerra has declined to guarantee a specific statewide construction total during his governorship.
Yet his housing platform contains measurable commitments.
He promises to declare a housing emergency on his first day, establish a team to accelerate production, and pursue financing for nearly 40,000 approved affordable units awaiting funds.
He also proposes public housing-production targets, a statewide affordability plan, and timelines for state project reviews.
His homelessness agenda proposes tracking spending and outcomes.
Voters can check whether these actions happen. They can also examine whether those actions ultimately produce more affordable homes or reduce homelessness.
As Parriva has examined in its coverage of California’s affordable housing budget, financing and implementation are critical to whether housing policies produce tangible benefits.
Creating a program is not the same as producing results.
Raman’s Promises: Outcomes Voters Can Measure
Raman has made several commitments that establish numerical benchmarks.
Her campaign platform proposes tripling annual housing construction. She has also pledged to reduce street homelessness by 50% before the 2028 Olympics and pursue the elimination of long-term encampments by the end of her first term.
She proposes expanding unarmed emergency response throughout Los Angeles, integrating it into 911 dispatch, and changing how the city evaluates homelessness spending.
Her homelessness target gives residents a specific outcome to assess. By 2028, they can ask whether the promised reduction occurred.
But a measurable target is not necessarily an achievable one.
LAist reported that the proposal faces significant challenges, including financing uncertainties and the difficulty of moving people into lasting housing.
The city will need a consistent baseline and measurement method. Fewer visible encampments would not necessarily mean an equivalent number of people obtained stable housing.
That difference is important for Latino communities. Parriva has previously examined how official homelessness counts can miss families experiencing severe housing insecurity.
Raman’s targets make certain outcomes easier to evaluate. Whether her administration can achieve them remains an open question.
What Research Says About Political Promises
Political science suggests that ambiguity can sometimes benefit candidates.
In a 2009 study published in the American Political Science Review, researchers Michael Tomz and Robert Van Houweling found that imprecise political positions can attract voter support.
But that research does not establish why Becerra avoids particular numerical guarantees. His stated concern about promising outcomes he cannot deliver offers another explanation.
A 2017 comparative study examined more than 20,000 election pledges across 12 countries. It found that governing parties often fulfill commitments, with success influenced by how power is shared.
The research suggests that promises can matter, but governing authority and institutional constraints affect what leaders can accomplish.
How Voters Can Hold Both Leaders Accountable
As California’s incoming governor and Los Angeles’ incoming mayor, Becerra and Raman will lead different levels of government, each with distinct powers and limitations.
California’s governor must work with the Legislature, state agencies, and local governments. Los Angeles’ mayor must navigate City Council decisions, municipal finances, and responsibilities shared with Los Angeles County.
Parriva recently examined a proposal to change the City Council’s authority over mayoral executive directives, illustrating why governing powers matter when evaluating promises.
Neither leader controls every factor affecting the outcomes they seek.
Five questions voters can use:
- What was promised? A government action, a measurable outcome, or both?
- When should it happen? Is there a deadline?
- Who controls the outcome? What other institutions must cooperate?
- How will progress be measured? Are results publicly available and independently verifiable?
- What happens if the promise is missed? Will the administration explain what went wrong and how it will respond?
Becerra’s first-day housing order offers an early test of whether a promised action occurs. Raman’s 2028 homelessness target provides a longer-term test of whether a promised outcome is achieved.
But neither test alone establishes whether residents are better off.
That requires looking beyond announcements and numerical targets to the results people experience: homes they can afford, stable housing, and services that work.
Both leaders have made promises. The public’s task is to distinguish what they did, what changed, and whether those changes improved people’s lives.







