A review of 351 products found that some Amazon holiday promotions offered little or no savings. Amazon disputes the findings. Here’s how shoppers can check prices before buying.
As millions of Americans prepare to shop for holiday gifts, Amazon is promoting some of its biggest discounts of the year. But a new investigation suggests that some of those advertised bargains may not be bargains at all. In some cases, shoppers could actually pay more during a major sales event than they would have paid weeks earlier.
The investigation, conducted by Groundwork Collaborative, examined 351 products Amazon promoted during its 2024 and 2025 Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales. Researchers compared the lowest prices offered during those events with prices available in the weeks leading up to them.
The findings challenge Amazon’s promise of deep holiday discounts.
Nearly three in 10 products examined, or 29.1%, were priced the same or higher during the sales events than they had been during the preceding 30 days. More concerning, 9.4% were actually more expensive during the promotional period.
When researchers extended the comparison to the previous 90 days, nearly 60% of the products offered no better price than shoppers could have found earlier.
The investigation also found that half of the products classified as having no real savings had been available at or below their advertised sale price on at least eight days during the preceding month.
In other words, shoppers may not be getting the exceptional bargains they believe they are finding when they see a red discount badge or a crossed-out original price.
Amazon Disputes the Findings
Amazon rejected the investigation, calling its methodology flawed and its conclusions inaccurate.
In a response published November 16, the company argued that the sample was too small and unrepresentative of the millions of products offered during its major sales events. Amazon also disputed the way researchers calculated previous prices, saying the analysis overlooked certain early promotional offers and included products that did not carry an official deal badge.
Amazon said its own review found that 98% of the products examined by Groundwork Collaborative were priced the same or lower than their prices during the previous 30 days. The company also said it has strengthened its pricing safeguards for 2026.
According to Amazon, products carrying its official deal badge must meet additional requirements, including being priced at or below their lowest price during the previous 30 days.
The disagreement highlights how difficult it can be for consumers to determine whether a promotional price represents genuine savings.
Why California Families Should Pay Attention
The findings are particularly relevant in California, where household budgets remain under pressure, and many families are looking for ways to stretch their money during the holiday season.
A recent analysis by UCLA’s Latino Policy and Politics Institute, based on a May 2026 survey of 8,578 California registered voters, found that Latino households were experiencing greater financial strain than non-Latino households.
Nearly one in four Latino respondents, or 23%, said they were struggling to pay for necessities, compared with 12% of non-Latino respondents.
The survey also found that 40% of Latino respondents had cut back on groceries or food quality during the previous two months, compared with 28% of non-Latino respondents. Latino respondents were also more likely to report taking on additional credit card debt or loans.
Although the survey did not examine Amazon purchases or deceptive discounts, its findings illustrate why misleading promotions can matter to families already making difficult financial decisions.
For consumers trying to manage holiday expenses, an advertised discount can be an incentive to make a purchase they might otherwise postpone. But when the savings are smaller than advertised, or nonexistent, the consequences can extend beyond a single purchase.
California Law Offers Some Protection
California has legal protections against misleading price comparisons.
Under Section 17501 of the state’s Business and Professions Code, retailers cannot advertise a former price unless it was the prevailing market price during the previous three months. If the former price dates back further, the advertisement must clearly identify when that price applied.
The law is intended to prevent businesses from artificially inflating original prices to make discounts appear more attractive.
However, the Groundwork investigation does not establish that Amazon violated California law. Determining whether a particular promotion is illegal requires examining the specific advertisement, pricing history, and circumstances.
California consumers who believe they have encountered deceptive advertising can submit complaints to the state Department of Justice.
How to Avoid Holiday Shopping Traps
Consumers do not have to take a retailer’s word that a discount is a bargain. A few simple steps can help prevent unnecessary spending.
Check the price history. Before purchasing an expensive item, look at its pricing history over the previous 30, 90 or even 180 days. Tools such as Keepa and CamelCamelCamel allow shoppers to track Amazon prices and identify whether a promotional price is genuinely lower.
Compare prices elsewhere. Check the same product at Walmart, Target, Best Buy and other retailers. A discount at one store does not necessarily mean it offers the lowest price.
Look beyond the discount percentage. A product advertised as 40% or 60% off may still be more expensive than its usual selling price. Focus on the actual amount you will pay rather than the promotional label.
Check the seller. Not every product listed on Amazon is sold directly by Amazon. Review the seller’s reputation, customer feedback, and return policies before making a purchase.
Watch for unnecessary urgency. Countdown clocks, limited-time offers, and low stock warnings can encourage shoppers to buy before comparing prices. Take time to determine whether the purchase is necessary.
Calculate the final cost. Include shipping, taxes, and any additional fees before deciding whether a deal makes financial sense.
Be careful with buy now, pay later offers. Splitting a purchase into smaller payments does not make it cheaper. Late payments and accumulated installments can create additional financial pressure.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta has also encouraged shoppers to compare products, research sellers, be suspicious of offers that seem too good to be true and use credit cards when possible because they provide additional options to dispute unauthorized or incorrect charges.
As the holiday shopping season accelerates, the biggest savings may come not from finding the most attractive discount, but from taking the time to determine whether the discount is real.
For families watching every dollar, knowing the difference between a genuine bargain and a clever marketing promotion can make a meaningful difference.








